Love the food here! Came to visit here with my mom while we were craving for Italian food. The staff were great! Tip: Also, this establishment does not accept card; They accept cash only!

Always expect a line out the door! Love pizza time it's a must while you are out walking and shopping on St. George Street. They have a plethora of pizza options, garlic rolls, calzones, potato balls, sodas and a few wines. The pizzas are always fresh, full of flavor and the cheese pull is to die for! The pizzas are sold by the slice and they only take cash (they do have an ATM machine inside if needed) The dinning room is always packed but there's always one or two ladies shuffling people are pins to make sure there's always a clean table available for your party. Pizza time is definitely a MUST

The dining experience was quite enjoyable, particularly due to the freshness and flavor of the pizza. It featured a well-balanced combination of sauce, cheese, and dough, no single element overwhelmed the palate. We also ordered two Italian potato balls; however, there was a noticeable difference in their quality. My potato balls tasted somewhat stale, couldnt tell if it was with the beef filling or the potato itself. In contrast, my friend's potato ball had a much better and noticeably different fresh taste. As it was a Saturday night, there was a line extending outside the pizza place, but it moved at a reasonable speed. Upon entering, customers are required to place their orders promptly, as there is no menu displayed at the front. This can be a bit challenging for first-time visitors, like myself, who may need to quickly assess the display to make a decision, creating a sense of urgency in the ordering process. Despite the busy atmosphere, we were able to find several empty tables to enjoy our meals comfortably.

The pizza, service and ambushed was really good but I wasn't expecting to pay $18.90 for two slices of pizzas... Yesssss they were specialty pizzas and they were tasty but a little expensive.

This place came highly recommended and after seeing longer lines I almost didn't eat here but I am glad that I did! I ordered the Grandma's pizza and garlic rolls. They grab a slice and throw it into the oven while you wail making it a bit awkward standing there but that is the best way to make sure it is not sitting under heat lamps. The pizza was so good, crispy but not hard. You can tell that the ingredients were fresh. Overall I believe that it is casually the best pizza I have had. Not in an over the top, making yummy noises kind of way but in a way that it knows that it is the best pizza and it is there to help you! Highly recommend and I will be back every chance I can.

A pretty good pizza joint located in the heart of St. Augustine on St. George street. I've been in the past and loved it so I came again and I'm glad I did. It is rated #2 in the US for best pizza (might be a stretch but I'll play along) and I do have tk say their pizza is great. The 4 star review is because of the prices. Two slices of pizza and 3 garlic rolls ran me a few cents (literally) under $20 bucks. Great pizza but not that great. There is also almost no cold air being circulated because of how small it is and the copious amounts of pizza ovens. It was disgustingly hot so we had to take the food to go after a few bites. I got the chicken parm pizza and the marinara sauce they put on it as well as the cheese was exceptional! The little chicken chunks were also very juicy and had a nice seasoning to it and round it out the pizza slice beautifully! I also loved the garlic rolls, they were toasted just the perfect amount and had a great amount of garlic and seasoning on it! It came with marinara sauce on the side which was good but a little watery for me. Relatively friendly workers here and I didn't have any issues except for when I asked for a box to go and the younger girl working there just kind of stared at me for a few seconds before saying okay and walking away. A little odd but I didn't think much of it because maybe she was just registering what I said because it was loud in there. Overall a great place to stop if you have money to burn but there are many pizza places around the area. You should stop here once at least, to say you've eaten here!

I have been wanting to try this place for a while now due their high praise on TripAdvisor. The first night we were in town while walking around we wanted to get a whole pizza to take back to the hotel, but the line was literally all the way up the street. On the last day in the area we made it a point to stop in early and grab a slice before they got too busy and share a slice. It's a cool spot inside and the staff were helpful and friendly. We got the white pizza with spinach and mushrooms. It was very good! I was flabbergasted by the amount of different pies they have. Wow! My mouth was watering and I felt like a fat kid in a candy shop. lol. I am sure each and every one is good too. The inside was somewhat packed even though it was just before 12 pm when we were there. It's more of an eat fast and get out type of place or grab a slice to go. I also had a Peroni beer to which always pairs well with pizza. Is the slice we ate in my opinion the second best pizza in the USA? No! But it's very good and I could eat it every day. I've had a ton of pizza that was better, but that's not saying one of their other slices wouldn't have knocked my d*ck off. I loved it and I'll be back the next time I am in town. It's a solid 8.2 Enjoy :D